Android management modes: device administrator vs work profile vs fully managed vs dedicated vs AOSP
Verdict: Device administrator is deprecated for GMS devices. Dedicated is the shared or kiosk mode and the only one supporting unattended Remote Help. AOSP is for devices without Google Mobile Services. Use OEMConfig, not custom OMA-URI, on Android Enterprise.
| Criterion | Device administrator | Personal work profile | Fully managed | Dedicated | AOSP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership and use | Legacy per-device | BYOD personal | Corporate single-user | Corporate shared or kiosk | Corporate, no GMS |
| Status | Deprecated for GMS devices | Current | Current | Current | Current (userless or user-associated) |
| Notable capability | None (migrate off) | Work data isolation | Full corporate control | Unattended Remote Help | Teams Rooms on Android and panels |
Rules
- Android device administrator management is deprecated and no longer available for devices with Google Mobile Services; migrate to an Android Enterprise method.
- Custom OMA-URI profiles do not support Android Enterprise; deliver OEM settings through OEMConfig, which reads a vendor schema from a Google Play app.
- Unattended Remote Help access, where the helper connects without the user accepting each time, requires the device enrolled as an Android Enterprise dedicated device.
- Android FOTA update management applies to fully managed, dedicated, and corporate-owned work profile (COPE) enrollment types via a device restrictions profile.
- AOSP corporate-owned devices without Google Mobile Services enrol as userless (shared) or user-associated (single user).
- Teams Rooms on Android, Teams phones and Teams panels enrol through AOSP Device Management and, unlike Teams Rooms on Windows, support OS version minimum and maximum compliance.
Traps
- A fully managed device with an assigned primary user is single-user; unattended Remote Help is documented only for dedicated devices.
- The Custom profile type supports Android device administrator, iOS/iPadOS, macOS and Windows, not Android Enterprise.